[#1DEER 1-I]

ON A SCALE OF 1 TO 10 HOW WOULD YOU RATE THIS BUCK? 1 BEING THE WORST 10 BEING THE BEST.

 

[elk22hunter]

My good friend just killed his twin brother this morning. I'm sure that he'll post some photo's here soon.

 

[callofthewild]

i give him a 6 as well. not a bad deer but there are better out there.

 

[Riverrat77]

Good mass with good deep forks.... I'd imagine he'll score quite well so I gave him an 8. True, there are bigger out there but thats a real beauty.

 

[Bears Butt]

I voted a 6, a nice deer no doubt about it. Very symetrical, with deep forks, those two things will score him high...mass? It lacks mass and that will put his score around the 160 range, maybe upper 150's.

 

[Riverrat77]

So.... P&Y but not B&C?

 

[sawsman]

I'm with Riverrat77 on this one and will rate him an 8. This is a nice buck, nice typical, deep forks and decent mass and he also has some nice eyegaurds. It looks to me like this buck was still fairly young by looking at his face. Some hunters will probably never bag a buck this nice. I have killed two bucks that are pretty close to the size of this one, but not quite as big. Maybe this will be the year..........

sawsman

 

[proutdoors]

A good buck, I rated him a 5. On a general area with archery gear, I would have to think about launching a muzzy tipped Gold Tip at him.

PRO

 

[SteepNDeep]

I give him little chance of survival - if I can get close enough tomorrow

 

[ts0hg]

This is a great buck. I would shoot him if I saw him. He has great deep forks. Nice eye gaurds. Looks slightly taller than wider, wich height is usually hard to find with width. The only reason that I did not rate him higher is that I think that he is not at his peak. He needs another couple of years. Plus if he is not taken he will be able to pass on his genes, wich look pretty good. 2-3 more years and this buck would be better than a 10.

 

[outdoorgirl]

i would say a 6.i would shoot him _O\

 

[coyoteslayer]

I think it just depends if I was hunting public land or if I had a limited entry tag

 

[12 Volt Man]

I voted it an 8. Bigger buck than I have ever shot.

 

[ridgetops]

I think it just depends if I was hunting public land or if I had a limited entry tag

I agree, are you talking Utah general season public land or the Henries or Arizona Strip?

 

[Dave B]

This guy is a solid seven. Not a monster but one stud of a buck! Im thinkin your gonna have to get in the 180 bracket to start getting eights and nines, just because its so many little things alot of great just don't have before they start scoring really well. And he would have to be ungodly to get a ten out of me.